ESG vs. Impact Investing: What Makes Them Different?

Every investor has a unique strategy walking into the global financial markets. Some seek short-term capital gains, while others target long-term income from dividends. Some new traders might prioritize environmental or social causes and seek to invest in companies aligned with their values.

In essence, these approaches are referred to as ESG (environmental, social, and governance) investing and impact investing. But what do these strategies entail precisely?

» New to stock trading? Here's 6 easy steps to get you started

ESG Investing Explained

In recent years, ESG investing has become a popular tool for institutional investors to grade companies on their efforts to be green, improve their social contributions, and bolster corporate governance. The concept began sometime in the 2010s as market observers purported that it was crucial to begin assessing non-financial metrics to evaluate businesses' sustainability and societal impacts.

The initiative works by directing capital toward corporations that promote ESG and acquiring stocks, bonds, exchange-traded funds (ETFs), mutual funds, CFDs, and other financial instruments.

At the same time, because the industry has been accused of greenwashing—claiming to be green without ever adopting environmental principles—it is critical to implement a few considerations in your ESG investing endeavors:

1. Scrutinize the credibility, reliability, and transparency of the ESG-related data and methodologies.
2. Be mindful of balancing financial risks and rewards and instituting common investment practices in your trading account.

» Ready to start trading CFDs? Discover how to open an account with Fortrade

Impact Investing Explained

Impact investing can often be confused with ESG investing because they share the same goals of trading based on creating environmental and social benefits. Impact investing was also established sometime in the 2010s to balance financial gains with environmental, social, and governance considerations. Ultimately, this capital will be prioritized for stocks and funds that choose beneficial outcomes for the planet, with financial gains coming in second.

Similar to ESG investing, it's crucial to thoroughly research and evaluate data, focusing on both its effectiveness and credibility. Indeed, the information and its authors must be held accountable throughout the process.

» Learn about higher margins with CFD stock trading

The Main Differences Between ESG and Impact Investing



1. Overall Approach/Framework vs. Individual Strategy

ESG investing offers a broader approach incorporating these ESG principles into investment decisions.

Impact investing focuses primarily on producing measurable and positive social and environmental impacts alongside pecuniary returns.

2. Fiduciary Scrutiny

In ESG trading, investors prioritize their fiduciary responsibility by considering specific factors that can impact long-term financial performance. In essence, ESG investing revolves around the fundamental idea that companies with robust ESG practices are better positioned for sustainable value creation.

On the other hand, impact investing enhances the concentration on accomplishing environmental and social outcomes.

3. Risk Profiles

Impact investing assesses risk on multiple fronts. Firstly, impact investing will look at risk management and mull over the risk of achieving the intended environmental and social impacts.

At the same time, ESG investing will hone in on managing and avoiding risks associated with ESG components. In other words, ESG investing targets firms with low-risk profiles and the possibility of long-term success.

» Find out if CFD positions can be held in the long term

4. Public vs. Private

The differences in this arena are negligible. Both ESG and impact investing use public and private investments as a factor in making investment decisions. The slight difference is that impact investing will determine the impact objective of private, public, and direct investments in projects and funds.

5. Cross-Definition Relationship

Ultimately, all impact funds are ESG-compliant, but not all ESG funds are impacted. In other words, ESG investing functions as the foundation for firms' risk profiles and sustainability evaluations. The impact will go above and beyond ESG considerations and actually measure these environmental and social impacts.

» Develop your trading skills: See our beginner trading courses and advanced trading courses

Which Approach Aligns Better With Your Values?

So, if you are looking to alter your trading account, is it time to embrace ESG and impact investing? If so, which one is the superior option for your values and your dollars? This can be tough to figure out, especially considering ESG is far more accessible and prevalent than impact. Indeed, ESG does the bare minimum for environmental, social, and governance causes.

» Explore the world of trading: Join the Fortrade community