Gold vs. Silver for Investing: Weighing the Pros & Cons

When considering precious metals for investment, gold and silver are two of the most popular choices. Both offer a hedge against inflation and economic uncertainty, but they come with distinct characteristics that could impact a trader's trading plan.

Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each metal is crucial for making an informed decision that aligns with the trader's financial goals.

» Interested in gold and silver? See our list of CFDs on other precious metals

Historical Performance and Notable Price Movements of Gold and Silver

Gold

Source: Tradingview



In recent decades, the value of gold (XAU) has increased significantly, often due to economic uncertainties and inflation. Gold was around $300 per ounce in the early 2000s, surged to over $1,900 in 2011 during the financial crisis, dipped below $1,100 in 2015, and reached new highs above $2,000 in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Gold's price movements often coincide with economic crises and concerns about inflation, making it a popular potential hedge against uncertainty.

» Learn more: Understanding XAU/USD

Silver

Source: Tradingview



Silver has been highly volatile. In 2001, it was around $4 per ounce, reaching nearly $50 in 2011 due to economic uncertainties and industrial demand. Unlike gold, silver's dual role as a precious metal and industrial commodity leads to more significant price swings.

It's volatility is influenced by monetary and industrial uses, economic uncertainty, increased industrial demand, the COVID-19 pandemic, supply disruptions, changes in mining output, and shifts in investor sentiment.

» Learn about other commodities in our guide to CFDs on agricultural commodities

Key Factors Driving Gold and Silver Demand

Gold

• Economic uncertainty: Gold is viewed as a safe-haven instrument, making it relatively stable.
• Inflation hedge: Historically, gold has maintained its value when paper currencies and paper trading accounts devalue.
• Central bank policies: Central banks hold significant gold reserves and may increase them during economic downturns or currency diversification, impacting global demand and prices.
• Geopolitical tensions: Gold is seen as a secure investment. This fact could increase its demand in cases of political instability.

» Learn how geopolitical tensions influence market volatility

» Confused about dividends? Here are some examples of oil dividend stocks to help you understand

Silver

• Industrial use: Silver is used in various industrial applications such as electronics, solar panels, and medical devices.
• Economic recovery: Increased manufacturing and technological innovations spur silver demand.
• Investment demand: Investors view silver as a lower-cost alternative to gold for hedging against market volatility.
• Renewable energy: Silver is used in photovoltaic cells, which are necessary in the solar power industry.

» Discover more tech innovations with these examples of tech penny stocks

» You should know these pros and cons of trading silver CFDs

Side-by-Side Comparison of Gold and Silver

» Here are some unique strategies to keep trading during flat markets

Popular Investment Forms for Gold and Silver

• Coins: Coins are highly liquid as they are a form of direct cash that possibility for ownership, which could increase value due to collectability while also being negatively affected by inflation. However, this comes with higher premiums compared to bars and carries additional costs due to storage.
• Bars: Offer lower premiums compared to coins with flexibility in investment amounts due to availability in various sizes. Like coins, bars also incur storage costs but are less liquid as they require a brokerage or merchant that is willing to purchase gold and silver bars.
• Mutual funds/ETFs: These are investment funds that track the price of gold without requiring physical storage or ownership. They are generally easily traded on stock exchanges and offer lower costs than physical silver and gold. However, they may not perfectly track silver prices and are highly subjected to market risks.
• Mining shares: This offers the chance to invest in gold and silver indirectly by backing the performance of companies that mine and produce silver and gold. They offer the possibility for dividends, but any potential profit is tied to the performance of mining companies regardless of the price of gold and thus has potentially higher volatility.
• CFDs and other derivatives: Silver and gold CFDs (contracts for difference) are financial instruments that allow traders to speculate on the price of gold and silver without owning the physical metal. They offer higher leverage and short-selling (the ability to potentially profit if the price drops) and could be traded often. However, leverage comes with added risk as it can also amplify your potential losses and spreads could also impact potential profits.

» Not sure which is for you? Here are the differences between CFDs and ETFs

Gold vs. Silver: A Detailed Analysis of Risk-Return Profiles

Gold

Gold is known for its stability and safe-haven status. It has historically provided moderate returns, often increasing in value during economic uncertainty and inflation.

However, its prices could be volatile in the short term due to currency fluctuations and geopolitical events. Despite this, gold tends to maintain its value over the long term, making it a reliable store of wealth.

» Wondering if USD is backed by gold?

The lack of income generation is a downside, but its diversification potential and low correlation with other instruments enhance its appeal.

» Interested in learning how to trade gold as a beginner?

Silver

Silver is more volatile than gold because it is both an industrial and a precious metal. Its prices are affected by industrial demand, economic cycles, and technological advancements.

From 1971 to 2021, silver's average annual return was about 6.5%, slightly lower than gold but with greater fluctuations. Due to strong industrial demand and investment speculation, silver surged to nearly $50 per ounce in 2011.

» Stay up to date with geopolitical events by learning to use an economic calendar

Gold vs. Silver: Tax Implications of Investing

In Europe, investment gold and silver like bullion coins and bars is usually exempt from VAT. However, capital gains tax (CGT) may apply when selling precious metals for a potential profit.

In the UK, gold investments held for over a year may be subject to CGT. Silver investments are typically subject to VAT, generally ranging from 20% to 25%, and are also subject to CGT when sold for a profit.

Insights to Mitigate Risks When Investing in Gold and Silver

1. Diversification: This involves spreading investments across various instrument classes, including gold, silver, stocks, and bonds.

2. Dollar-cost averaging: This strategy reduces the impact of market volatility by averaging the purchase price over time, smoothing out short-term price variations.

3. Hedging: Hedging means using financial instruments or derivatives like options or CFDs to take an opposing position in a particular instrument with the intention to offset potential losses, thus hedging against price movements.

» Here are some beginner insights for stock trading

Gold vs. Silver: Making the Right Choice

The most important consideration for investors deciding between gold and silver is their investment goals and risk tolerance. Gold presents an opportunity for stability and acts as a hedge against economic uncertainty, while silver provides higher potential returns but with greater volatility due to its industrial demand.

Understanding personal financial goals and risk is crucial in making an informed choice.

» Ready to start trading? Learn more about opening a Fortrade account